Understanding Watchtower and Latest Tags in Your Homelab

BigBearBlog
1

Hey Big Bear Community! If you’re running Docker containers in your homelab, you’ve probably encountered discussions about Watchtower and the latest tag. These tools can be great for automating container updates and many homelab users run them successfully. However, it’s important to understand their behavior and potential risks so you can decide if they’re right for your setup.

Understanding Watchtower

Watchtower is a powerful tool that automatically updates your containers when new images are released. While many users run it successfully in their homelabs, it’s important to understand how it works and consider some potential challenges:

1. Surprise Breaking Changes

When working with Home Assistant, automatic updates might occasionally require configuration adjustments. For example, if an update changes how integrations work or modifies entity IDs, you may need to review and update your automations and dashboard configurations. While these situations are not common with minor version updates, being aware of potential changes helps you maintain a stable smart home environment.

2. Database Disasters

Many homelab services (like Home Assistant, NextCloud, or PhotoPrism) use databases. Automatic updates can sometimes include database schema changes. If Watchtower updates these containers without proper migration steps, you might end up with corrupted data or services that refuse to start.

3. Storage Mount Mayhem

In homelabs, we often use bind mounts or volumes for persistent storage. I’ve seen cases where automatic updates changed the internal structure of containers, leading to permission issues or missing data. Fixing these usually requires manual intervention - exactly what we were trying to avoid!

4. Network Stack Conflicts

If you’re running services that depend on specific network configurations (like Pi-hole, Traefik, or nginx-proxy-manager), an automatic update might change the network stack requirements, breaking your carefully planned network setup.

The Latest Tag Troubles

Using the latest tag feels natural - after all, why wouldn’t we want the latest version? Here’s what could go wrong in your homelab:

1. The Dependency Dance

In a homelab, services often depend on each other. Let’s say you’re running:

version: '3'
services:
  nextcloud:
    image: nextcloud:latest
  mariadb:
    image: mariadb:latest

One day, the MariaDB image updates to a new major version, but your NextCloud version isn’t compatible with it. Boom! Your personal cloud is down.

2. Different Architectures, Different Problems

Many of us run homelabs on various hardware - from old x86 machines to Raspberry Pis. The latest tag might pull an image that’s not optimized for your architecture, or worse, not compatible at all. I learned this the hard way when trying to run certain containers on my RPi 4.

3. Resource Surprises

New versions might have different resource requirements. That container that was running fine on your low-power NAS might suddenly need twice the RAM after an update to latest. Not fun when you’re working with limited hardware!

Better Ways to Manage Your Homelab

Here’s how I now manage my homelab containers after learning these lessons:

1. Pin Those Versions!

Instead of:

image: homeassistant/home-assistant:latest

Use:

image: homeassistant/home-assistant:2025.1.1

2. Use Docker Compose for Version Control

Create a git repository for your docker-compose files. This way, you can track changes and easily roll back if something goes wrong. Here’s a simple example:

version: '3'
services:
  pihole:
    image: pihole/pihole:2024.07.0
    volumes:
      - ./pihole/etc-pihole:/etc/pihole
      - ./pihole/etc-dnsmasq.d:/etc/dnsmasq.d
    environment:
      TZ: 'Your/Timezone'
    restart: unless-stopped

3. Set Up a Test Environment

Even in a homelab, having a test environment is valuable. I use a separate docker-compose file with -test suffixed containers to try updates before applying them to my main services.

4. Create Update Routines

Instead of automatic updates, set aside some “homelab maintenance time” (I do it monthly). During this time:

  • Check release notes for your containers
  • Test updates in your test environment
  • Take backups (especially important for databases!)
  • Update services one at a time
  • Document what you changed (future you will thank present you)

Security Considerations

When managing container updates, security is a crucial factor to consider:

Supply Chain Attacks

Supply chain attacks have become increasingly common in the container ecosystem:

  • Attackers might compromise a container image repository
  • Malicious code could be injected into automated builds
  • Dependencies in base images might be compromised
  • Auto-updating containers could pull compromised images before they’re detected

To protect against supply chain attacks:

  • Use official images from trusted sources
  • Consider running your own container registry as a cache
  • Hash-pin your base images in multi-stage builds
  • Use image signing and verification when possible
  • Be cautious with third-party container images, especially if they auto-update

Security Patches and Updates

Missing security updates can leave your homelab vulnerable. While manual updates give you more control, they also require you to stay informed about security patches and critical updates for your containers. Consider:

  • Setting up notifications for security advisories of the containers you use
  • Following the official repositories or Discord channels of your key applications
  • Regularly checking for security-related updates, especially for containers exposed to the internet
  • Implementing vulnerability scanning for your containers

Latest Tag Security Implications

Using the latest tag can pose security risks:

  • Different servers might pull different versions of latest at different times
  • You can’t verify which version contains a specific security patch
  • It’s harder to audit which version was running when investigating security incidents
  • Rolling back after a security issue becomes more complicated
  • Supply chain attacks can target popular latest tags for maximum impact

Finding the Right Balance

The key is finding the right balance between automation and control:

  1. For critical security updates, you want to apply them quickly
  2. For regular updates, you might want more control and testing
  3. Consider using automated security scanning tools to identify vulnerable containers
  4. Document your update policy and security review process
  5. Maintain an inventory of your container sources and their trust levels

Backup Best Practices

Before updating containers, it’s essential to have proper backups in place:

  1. Use Application-Specific Backup Features
  • Many applications like Home Assistant provide built-in backup capabilities
  • These backups often include both configuration and data
  • Test restoring from these backups regularly
  1. Volume Backup Strategies
  • Use bind mounts to include Docker volumes in your system backup solution
  • Consider using Docker volume backup tools for consistent backups
  • Keep backups of your docker-compose files in version control
  • Document your volume locations and backup procedures
  1. Container Configuration Management
  • Store all container configurations in a git repository
  • Document any custom modifications
  • Keep copies of environment files (.env) secure but backed up
  • Maintain a list of all running containers and their dependencies

Remember to regularly test your backup restoration process to ensure it works when needed.

Conclusion

While Watchtower and latest tags seem convenient, it’s important to understand their behaviors and potential implications for your homelab setup. Take control of your updates, keep good backups, and enjoy a more stable homelab environment. Remember, it’s better to understand and plan your updates than to be surprised by unexpected changes!